CARLOS UNFILTERED

The polite email that nearly cost a family business $118,000

The polite email that nearly cost a family business $118,000

A Melbourne family business nearly paid $118,000 to criminals who were sitting inside a genuine email thread with its supplier. Victoria Police has had 107 reports of the same scam since July. Hospitality pays its suppliers exactly this way.

This one is not an opinion. It is a warning, and I want every owner who pays an invoice by bank transfer to read it twice.

Here is how it happened, in Victoria Police's telling. A staff member at a furniture business in Melbourne's Bayside area spent two weeks in late August and early September emailing a supplier about a $118,000 order. The emails were real. The supplier was real. Then an email arrived in the same thread, from the same conversation, saying the supplier's bank account had changed and the payment was urgent. She paid. It was a scam. The criminals had got into the email thread and were replying inside it.

The money was only recovered because her bank flagged the transfer, she rang the supplier on a number she already had, and police and the federal cybercrime centre blocked it. That is luck and a fast bank. Most do not get the money back.

The scale is the frightening bit. Victoria Police's cybercrime squad says 107 reports of this exact scam since July. The National Anti-Scam Centre puts payment redirection losses at $166.8 million in 2025, second only to investment scams and up 9 per cent on the year before. This week business advisers were still being quoted warning that the fake email which says "our bank details have changed" is the one that worries them most.

Now think about how a cafe, a club or a restaurant pays its bills. Coffee, milk, produce, meat, linen, gas, the fit-out guy, the fridge mechanic. Dozens of invoices a week, most of them emailed, most of them paid by someone busy, between the breakfast rush and the lunch prep, from a phone. Every one of those is a thread a criminal can sit in. And the change of bank details email does not look suspicious. It looks like admin.

Here is the part owners need to understand about who carries the loss. A court in Western Australia has already ruled on a case where a contractor's email was hacked, the bank details on a real invoice were changed, and the customer paid $235,000 to the criminals. The court made the customer pay the invoice again, in full, because they did not independently check the new details. Pay the wrong account and you may well still owe the right one.

The rule, and it is one rule

No change to a supplier's bank details is ever accepted from an email. Not from a reply in a thread you started. Not with an urgent note attached. Not with the boss's name on it. You pick up the phone and you ring the supplier on the number you already have, from an old invoice or your contacts, never the number in the new email, and a human confirms it. If they cannot be reached, the payment waits. No supplier worth keeping will complain about that call. Most will thank you.

And four habits around it

  • Two people on big payments. Anything over a figure you set, say a few thousand dollars, needs a second person to approve it. Scams rely on one busy person acting alone.
  • Urgency is the tell. Real suppliers do not need a payment in the next hour. The moment an email pushes you to hurry, slow down.
  • Lock the inbox. Two-factor authentication on every email account in the business, including the owner's. Ask whoever looks after your IT to alert you if your mailbox starts forwarding emails somewhere else, because that is how the criminals read your threads.
  • Know the first hour. If money has gone to the wrong account, ring your bank immediately, then report it to ReportCyber and your state police. The chance of recovery falls by the hour.

Suppliers, this is for you too. If your email is compromised, your customers are the ones who get robbed in your name. Lock your accounts down, and tell every customer in writing that you will never change bank details by email alone. That one sentence on your invoice protects both of you.

The furniture business got its $118,000 back. The 106 other reports to Victoria Police since July mostly did not make the news, which tells you how those ended. One phone call. That is the whole defence.

Stay caffeinated. I'm out.

Carlos

Sources: Victoria Police, National Anti-Scam Centre (ACCC), ABC News, SmartCompany, Mobius Group v Inoteq (District Court of Western Australia).