CARLOS UNFILTERED

Seven trolleys, one lesson

Seven trolleys, one lesson

The ABC followed seven households through their weekly shop this week. Budgets of $80 to $300, three supermarkets to save a few dollars, meat cut, fruit swapped for frozen. That is your customer at the counter.

On Monday 9 November 2026 the ABC published a piece that every cafe owner should read before they next complain about customers. Seven households, their trolleys itemised, their budgets on the record.

A young dad with a toddler and a baby, budgeting $250 a week, shopping at Aldi, steak gone, cheaper cheese in. A family of three on $300, starting at one supermarket and finishing at another to fill the gaps. A woman shopping three places every week, buying lentils and ghee in bulk. A mother on a disability pension whose groceries take almost a quarter of it, now buying discounted ready meals because it is cheaper than cooking for one. A single mum of two boys on a strict $150, with a $15 food bank parcel supplying most of the fresh produce. A pensioner on under $80 a week who has given up biscuits. Another who pays more because an injury means she cannot shop around.

Canstar says one in four shoppers has changed how they shop in the last year to cut costs. Food bank demand is up by 100,000 households. The share of income going on essentials has risen by almost 6 per cent in three years, and more for people on their own.

The piece ends with a line that should sting a little in this trade: for some people, cutting back means fewer takeaway lattes.

Here is what I take from it. Not a single one of those seven households is tight with money. They are careful with it. There is a difference, and a cafe that cannot tell the difference will get the next year wrong.

A customer who drives to three supermarkets to save $15 has not stopped valuing things. They have started valuing them properly. When that person spends $5 on a coffee, it is a decision, made against the cheese they downgraded and the steak they stopped buying. It is not a habit any more. It is a choice. Your job is to be worth choosing.

So no, I do not think the answer is a cheaper coffee. A cheaper coffee made with cheaper beans and rushed by a stretched barista is the fastest way to lose the careful customer. They know what things cost now. They can tell. What they are weighing is not price. It is whether the thing was worth it.

What "worth it" looks like to a careful customer

  • The same every time. A regular who has cut their coffees from five a week to two is not forgiving the bad one. Consistency is the whole product now.
  • No surprises on the bill. If there is a public holiday surcharge or a price rise, say it on the board, not on the receipt. The careful customer does not mind paying. They mind being caught.
  • One small thing you did not have to do. The name remembered, the extra few seconds of care on the milk, the honest "the new blend is sweeter, you might prefer the old one". These cost nothing and they are why someone picks you over the place closer to the station.
  • A reason to stay. Someone on a tight week who cannot afford to go out often will still go somewhere that feels like a treat. A clean table, a smile and a coffee made properly is a treat for five dollars. Make sure it feels like one.

And to the drinkers reading this. If the second coffee has gone from your week, that is your call and nobody in this trade should make you feel bad about it. Just know the difference between a cafe that charged you $5 and gave you something made with care by someone paid properly, and one that charged you $5 for whatever came out of the machine. In a careful year, spend your coffee money where it is respected.

Seven trolleys. One lesson. Your customer is not spending less because they stopped caring. They are spending less because they care more about every dollar than they used to. Earn the ones they bring you.

Stay caffeinated. I'm out.

Carlos

Sources: ABC News (9 November 2026), Canstar, Foodbank Australia, HILDA Survey.