CARLOS UNFILTERED

Victoria, you voted for this. Now vote like it matters

Victoria, you voted for this. Now vote like it matters

Victoria goes to the polls on Saturday 28 November. Nobody did this to Victorians. They voted for it, more than once. This time, vote like the result matters.

I am going to say something that will get me letters. Victoria, nobody did this to you. You did it.

The same side has run the state for twelve years. Daniel Andrews was premier for nearly nine of them. Melbourne spent 262 days in lockdown, among the longest of any city in the world. Small businesses were shut by order, cafes and restaurants worst of all, and a lot of them never reopened. And in November 2022, with all of that fresh, Victorians went to the polls and gave the same government another four years.

Then, in May this year, the government confirmed it was spending $134,304 of public money on a bronze statue of him, to stand outside the Treasury offices in the middle of Melbourne. To be fair, the new premier, Ben Carroll, scrapped it in August. But somebody signed that contract, and it tells you plenty about where their heads were.

Now look at what twelve years bought.

The bill

  • Debt. Net debt is forecast at $165.3 billion this year and $199.3 billion by 2029-30. Ratings agency S&P says it is the highest in Australia. One analysis puts it above New South Wales and Queensland combined.
  • Interest. The interest alone is $8.9 billion a year, heading to $11.8 billion. That is $24.4 million every single day, rising to more than $32 million. Before one nurse is paid or one road is fixed.
  • Roads. The Victorian Auditor-General found 48 per cent of the state road network was in poor or very poor condition, up from 39 per cent in 2021. The transport department said it needed more than $3 billion to keep up. It was given $1.04 billion.
  • Crime. There were 624,624 criminal offences recorded in the year to June 2026. That is down 2.1 per cent, and I will give credit for that, but it comes off the highest rate in years. Shoplifting is still rising, and Victoria Police was 1,340 officers short at the end of August.
  • Business. The Business Council of Australia ranked Victoria last in the country as a place to do business in 2026.

Somebody has to pay $11 billion a year in interest. There is no magic pot. It comes out of land tax, payroll tax, levies and charges, which means it comes out of every business with a front door, and every renter whose landlord passes it on.

Melbourne was named the world's most liveable city seven years running, up to 2017. It is still third on that list, behind Copenhagen and Vienna, and on a good day it is one of the great cities on earth for food and coffee. That is exactly what makes this so frustrating. What on earth happened? If I lived there and ran a business, I would be looking hard at the border.

What is on offer this time

  • Labor has promised to roll back its own land tax changes over six years, waive stamp duty for businesses forced to restructure out of discretionary trusts, extend standard pub trading to 3am, approve simple fit-outs in ten business days, and spend an extra $352 million to fix 500,000 potholes.
  • The Coalition has promised to lift the payroll tax-free threshold to $1.2 million by 2028-29, cut the metropolitan payroll tax rate to 4.8 per cent from 2030-31, bring in no new taxes, and spend $5 billion over four years on roads, including one million potholes.
  • One Nation says it would lift the payroll tax threshold and remove stamp duty on setting up a new business.

I am not going to tell you which box to number first. That is your business. I will tell you how I would judge it.

Four questions for anyone who wants your vote

  • How do you pay down the debt, and by when? Not "stabilise". Pay down. With a date.
  • When does the relief actually start? A tax cut in 2030-31 is two elections away. A six-year rollback is six budgets that can change.
  • Does it reach a business my size? Payroll tax thresholds do nothing for a small cafe already under them. Land tax relief helps whoever owns the building. If you lease, ask how it reaches you.
  • Who is accountable when it does not happen? A name, not a department.

Here is the blunt version. If you are happy with the debt, the roads and the cost of doing business, vote for more of the same. That is your right. But if you are not, you do not get to re-elect it and then complain for another four years. Voting the same way and expecting a different result is not loyalty. It is a habit.

Maybe this time is different. I hope so, for the sake of every operator in Melbourne, Geelong, Ballarat and Bendigo who is still standing after the last six years. Victoria is too good a place to be run this badly.

Vote, and vote like it matters. Because the interest bill certainly does.

Stay caffeinated. I'm out.

Carlos

Sources: ABC News, SBS News, AAP, Victorian Auditor-General's Office, Crime Statistics Agency Victoria, Victoria Police, Economist Intelligence Unit, The Conversation, SmartCompany.